Fails the Bechdel test

City of Joy

1992. Directed by Roland Joffé, written by Dominique Lapierre and Mark Medoff.

The Bechdel test

Bechdel score

1 / 3

Fails

  1. Yes 1. At least two women
    6 women characters. 2 of them speak.
  2. No 2. Who talk to each other
    Our parser found no scene where two women talk to each other.
  3. No 3. About something besides a man
    Not reached: the film fails an earlier rule.

Second opinion

Not rated bechdeltest.com readers haven't rated this film.

Poster for City of Joy

The film

Independent of each other, the Pal family - parents Hazari and Kamla, and their three offspring Amrita, Shambu and Manooj - and Max Lowe arrive in Calcutta, their initial dealings there being less than positive. After losing their farm in the nearby countryside to the "money lender", the Pals are in the city in search of a better life, especially in wanting to build a dowry for Amrita who is now of marrying age. Max, a Houston based surgeon who fell into the career as a matter of family obligation, quit his job unable to cope with the emotional toll especially of losing patients, and has come to Calcutta in search of spiritual enlightenment. Their lives converge by chance in the slum neighborhood nicknamed the City of Joy, most specifically at the makeshift City of Joy Clinic and School opened and operated by Irishwoman Joy Bethel who came to Calcutta on a whim and never left. While the Pals eventual settle in the City of Joy, Joy herself tries to convince Max to provide his much needed medical services to the clinic, which he eventually but reluctantly agrees for as long as he is in Calcutta, which is longer than he may have originally planned if only in having troubles trying to get back to the US. In addition to some seeing Max as having no long term commitment to the neighborhood like the Pals who are now residents, two others issues in combination threaten the lives of those in the City of Joy, including Max, Joy and the Pals, and the livelihood of the clinic: the broadening of the services to include a nearby leper colony, some in the neighborhood who do not want to associate with them; and the control of the neighborhood by the corrupt Ghatak family - the patriarchal Godfather as he is referred to and his more violent son Ashok - who own much of the neighborhood property, own many of the neighborhood services (such as the rickshaw services, Hazari who has gotten a job as one of their rickshaw drivers) and who require "protection money" from other neighborhood businesses such as from the clinic to maintain the peace.

Released
17 Apr 1992
Genres
Crime, Drama
Rated
PG-13
IMDb
6.5 / 10
Awards
1 nomination
Elsewhere
View on IMDb

Starring, by lines spoken

  • Women
  • Men
  • Not in the cast list
  • Bigger name, more lines
  1. Max 210 lines, man
  2. Hasari 130 lines, man
  3. Joan 71 lines, woman
  4. Ram 38 lines, man
  5. Ashoka 35 lines, man
  6. Betsy 21 lines
  7. Ghatak 20 lines, man
  8. Gangooly 19 lines, man
  9. Aloka 16 lines
  10. Anouar 15 lines, man
Full cast, 21 people
  • Patrick Swayze as Max Lowe
  • Om Puri as Hazari Pal
  • Pauline Collins as Joan Bethel
  • Shabana Azmi as Kamla H. Pal
  • Ayesha Dharker as Amrita H. Pal
  • Art Malik as Ashok Ghatak
  • Nabil Shaban as Anouar
  • Suneeta Sengupta as Poomina
  • Shyamanand Jalan as Ghatak - Godfather
  • Rudraprasad Sengupta as Chomotkar
  • Anjan Dutt
  • Masood Akhtar
  • Loveleen Mishra
  • Pavan Malhotra
  • Anashua Majumdar
  • Satya Bandopadhyay
  • Sujan Mukherjee
  • Chitra Sen
  • Debatosh Ghosh as Ram Chander
  • Mansi Upadhyay as Meeta
  • Shyamal Sengupta as Gangooly - Con man

Who talks, scene by scene

Lines of dialogue in every 4 scenes, start to finish. Women above the line, men below. 12% of lines come from characters we couldn't match to the cast list and aren't shown.

Women

Men

Scene 1 Scene 172

Hover, tap or tab to a bar to see those scenes: where they happen and who's talking.

Show the numbers
ScenesWomen's linesMen's lines
1 to 424
5 to 8011
9 to 12016
13 to 16011
17 to 2016
21 to 2402
25 to 2807
29 to 3208
33 to 36013
37 to 4006
41 to 44015
45 to 48012
49 to 521527
53 to 56018
57 to 6033
61 to 64213
65 to 681334
69 to 72612
73 to 761639
77 to 80833
81 to 84218
85 to 88024
89 to 92717
93 to 96313
97 to 100012
101 to 10411
105 to 10817
109 to 11206
113 to 116013
117 to 12012
121 to 124011
125 to 12811
129 to 132111
133 to 136032
137 to 140010
141 to 14428
145 to 14807
149 to 15206
153 to 156316
157 to 16003
161 to 16419
165 to 168126
169 to 172013

The evidence

  • Straight from the script
  • Counted from the script and the credits

Tap an exhibit to open it.

Exhibit A: every 100 lines

Out of every 100 lines with a known speaker, 14 are women's.

90 lines from women, 556 from men.

  • Women
  • Men

Exhibit B: who's in it

6 women and 11 men in the cast. 2 women and 4 men from it get lines.

Characters

With lines

  • Women
  • Men

Exhibit C: who gets heard

The first woman speaks at line 2 of 737. The longest stretch with no woman speaking runs 86 lines.

Every line of dialogue, first to last

  • First line by a woman
  • Longest stretch with no woman speaking

Words spoken

Women speak 15% of the words (1,175), men 85% (6,925). Women have 14% of the lines, so their lines run longer than men's.

Exhibit D: the test the other way

Two named men talk to each other about something besides a woman. It passes the reverse test.

Conversations between two named characters

Exhibit E: behind the camera

None of the 9 people in these jobs are women. Across the whole crew, 0% of the people whose gender is listed are women.

Directed by
Roland Joffé (man)
Written by
Mark Medoff (man), Dominique LaPierre (man)
Produced by
Jake Eberts (man), Roland Joffé (man)
Shot by
Peter Biziou (man)
Edited by
Gerry Hambling (man), Hervé de Luze (man)
Music by
Ennio Morricone (man)

The crew, department by department

  • Directing

    0 women, 3 men

  • Camera

    0 women, 2 men

  • Editing

    0 women, 2 men

  • Production

    0 women, 2 men

  • Writing

    0 women, 2 men

  • Other crew

    0 women, 1 men

  • Sound

    0 women, 1 men

  • Women
  • Men
  • Gender not listed on TMDB

Exhibit F: how old the stars were

Women: 35 on average. Men: 46 on average. The top-billed cast, at the film's release.

Women

Ayesha Dharker 14, Shabana Azmi 41, Pauline Collins 51

Men

Patrick Swayze 39, Art Malik 39, Nabil Shaban 39, Om Puri 41, Rudraprasad Sengupta 57, Shyamanand Jalan 58

Exhibit G: the money

It made 54% of what it cost.

Budget
$27 million
Box office
$14.7 million

From TMDB, not adjusted for inflation.

About this analysis

Our parser read the script: 172 scenes and 737 lines of dialogue. How the test works

Related films

Back to the whole shelf