Passes the Bechdel test

Tall in the Saddle

1944. Directed by Edwin L. Marin, written by Michael Hogan and Paul Fix and Gordon Ray Young.

The Bechdel test

Bechdel score

3 / 3

Passes

  1. Yes 1. At least two women
    3 women characters. 2 of them speak.
  2. Yes 2. Who talk to each other
    In 4 scenes out of 173.
  3. Yes 3. About something besides a man
    In those scenes, our script parser found no man named. See the scene.

Second opinion

Not rated bechdeltest.com readers haven't rated this film.

Poster for Tall in the Saddle

The film

When a stranger arrives in a western town he finds that the rancher who sent for him has been murdered. Further, most of the townsfolk seem to be at each other's throats, and the newcomer has soon run contrariwise to most of them.

Released
29 Sep 1944
Genres
Drama, Western
Rated
Approved
IMDb
6.9 / 10
Elsewhere
View on IMDb

Starring, by lines spoken

  • Women
  • Men
  • Not in the cast list
  • Bigger name, more lines
  1. Rocklin 263 lines, man
  2. Dave 129 lines, man
  3. Arly 99 lines, woman
  4. Miss Martin 80 lines, woman
  5. Garvey 65 lines, man
  6. Harolday 45 lines, man
  7. Clint 43 lines, man
  8. Jackson 42 lines, man
  9. Clara 40 lines, woman
  10. Bob Clews 30 lines, man
Full cast, 36 people
  • John Wayne as Rocklin
  • Ella Raines as Arleta 'Arly' Harolday
  • Ward Bond as 'Judge' Robert Garvey
  • George 'Gabby' Hayes as Dave
  • Audrey Long as Clara Cardell
  • Elisabeth Risdon as Miss Elizabeth Martin
  • Donald Douglas as Harolday
  • Paul Fix as Bob Clews
  • Russell Wade as Clint Harolday
  • Emory Parnell as Sheriff Jackson
  • Raymond Hatton as Zeke
  • Harry Woods as George Clews
  • Frank Puglia as Talo (uncredited)
  • Clem Bevans as Card Game Spectator (uncredited)
  • Victor Adamson as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Erville Alderson as Wells Fargo Clerk (uncredited)
  • Walter Baldwin as Stan - Depot Master (uncredited)
  • Hank Bell as Hotel Clerk (uncredited)
  • Wheaton Chambers as Ab Jenkins (uncredited)
  • George Chandler as Saddle Maker (uncredited)
  • Victor Cox as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Frank Darien as Train Station Master (uncredited)
  • William Desmond as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Bobby Hale as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Russell Hopton as Wagon Driver (uncredited)
  • Ben Johnson as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Cy Kendall as Cap - Bartender (uncredited)
  • Sam McDaniel as Servant (uncredited)
  • Robert McKenzie as Doc Riding (uncredited)
  • Frank Orth as 'Shorty' Davis (uncredited)
  • Jim Reeves as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Russell Simpson as Pat Foster (uncredited)
  • Tom Smith as Townsman (uncredited)
  • William Steele as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Jack Tornek as Townsman (uncredited)
  • Eddy Waller as Santa Inez Depot Master (uncredited)

Who talks, scene by scene

Lines of dialogue in every 4 scenes, start to finish. Women above the line, men below. 6% of lines come from characters we couldn't match to the cast list and aren't shown.

Women

Men

Scene 1 Scene 173

Hover, tap or tab to a bar to see those scenes: where they happen and who's talking.

Show the numbers
ScenesWomen's linesMen's lines
1 to 405
5 to 8414
9 to 1214
13 to 16326
17 to 202196
21 to 2400
25 to 2826
29 to 32011
33 to 36062
37 to 40512
41 to 44213
45 to 483037
49 to 52617
53 to 56016
57 to 6001
61 to 64334
65 to 6875
69 to 72212
73 to 761869
77 to 80827
81 to 84012
85 to 88824
89 to 92311
93 to 96020
97 to 10039
101 to 1042615
105 to 10801
109 to 112010
113 to 116024
117 to 120631
121 to 12418
125 to 128516
129 to 13223
133 to 136104
137 to 14038
141 to 14444
145 to 14823
149 to 15221
153 to 15649
157 to 16020
161 to 164712
165 to 16849
169 to 1721114
173 to 17346

The evidence

  • Straight from the script
  • Counted from the script and the credits

Tap an exhibit to open it.

Exhibit A: the passing scenes

The scene our parser counted as passing, word for word.

CLARA: Auntie -- MISS MARTIN: With my dyspepsia? Do you want to kill me? CLARA: Aren't you going to have any supper?
CLARA: Oh. ARLY: I've a message for you -- from Harolday.
CLARA: We-el, not exactly moving in. You see... MISS MARTIN: Do you have to discuss our private affairs with every rag-tag-and-bobtail cow-person we meet, Clara? CLARA: Auntie!
MISS MARTIN: We can do very well without it -- thank you. And you're keeping your lady friend waiting. ARLY: I thought maybe you'd changed your mind again.
CLARA: I don't know how I can ever thank you for trying to help me. I do appreciate it ever so much -- Don't think too harshly of me, will you -- I… ARLY: She's lovely, isn't she? -- So sweet -- honest, and helpless. ARLY: Pity you didn't fall in love with her, instead of me.

Exhibit B: every 100 lines

Out of every 100 lines with a known speaker, 23 are women's.

219 lines from women, 721 from men.

  • Women
  • Men

Exhibit C: who's in it

3 women and 33 men in the cast. 2 women and 17 men from it get lines.

Characters

With lines

  • Women
  • Men

Exhibit D: who gets heard

The first woman speaks at line 31 of 997. The longest stretch with no woman speaking runs 89 lines.

Every line of dialogue, first to last

  • First line by a woman
  • Longest stretch with no woman speaking

Words spoken

Women speak 23% of the words (2,212), men 77% (7,252).

Exhibit E: the test the other way

Two named men talk to each other about something besides a woman. It passes the reverse test.

Conversations between two named characters

Exhibit F: behind the camera

None of the 8 people in these jobs are women. Across the whole crew, 0% of the people whose gender is listed are women.

Directed by
Edwin L. Marin (man)
Written by
Michael Hogan (man), Paul Fix (man)
Story by
Gordon Ray Young (man)
Produced by
Robert Fellows (man)
Shot by
Robert De Grasse (man)
Edited by
Philip Martin (man)
Music by
Roy Webb (man)

The crew, department by department

  • Other crew

    0 women, 5 men

  • Art

    0 women, 4 men

  • Sound

    0 women, 4 men

  • Writing

    0 women, 3 men

  • Costume & Make-Up

    0 women, 2 men

  • Directing

    0 women, 2 men

  • Production

    0 women, 2 men

  • Camera

    0 women, 1 men

  • Women
  • Men
  • Gender not listed on TMDB

Exhibit G: how old the stars were

Women: 34 on average. Men: 42 on average. The top-billed cast, at the film's release.

Women

Audrey Long 22, Ella Raines 24, Elisabeth Risdon 57

Men

Russell Wade 27, John Wayne 37, Donald Douglas 39, Ward Bond 41, Paul Fix 43, Emory Parnell 51, George 'Gabby' Hayes 59

About this analysis

Our parser read the script: 173 scenes and 997 lines of dialogue. How the test works

Related films

Back to the whole shelf